Listed in Cake Service
- 2094 Five Mile Line Road, Penfield, NY 14526, USA
- (585) 385-2253
About Upper Crust Cakery
The Upper Crust Cakery passion is to create exquisite cakes and mouth-watering desserts that both look incredible and taste delicious. We take advance orders and have a retail storefront as well.
Upper Crust Cakery serves the Greater Rochester area and the Finger Lakes Region. It’s most popular for its wide variety of cakes, “colossal” cupcakes and cutout cookies made daily. Perhaps most entertaining for customers is the chance to flip through the thick photo album that shows the vast array of creative products sold, from a fake cherry pie cupcake to a penguin cake, to a cookies that resemble the characters in “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer.”
Cakes are made with six different cake bases, and new flavors, including chocolate chip cookie dough and red velvet, will be unveiled at the grand opening.
Julie is SO amazing. Seriously, just go and taste some of her cupcakes. You’ll be hooked! She worked with us and made us an INCREDIBLY beautiful and delicious cake! Each layer was a different flavor!! The cake is SOO moist which isn’t typical of wedding cakes. Most cakes you eat at weddings are pretty on the outside but dry and bland on the inside. NOT with Julie’s cakes! They are equally as delicious and moist as they are stunning.
Our experience with Upper Crust Cakery was great from start to finish. They were incredibly friendly and professional. The cake tasting was overwhelming because THEY DO NOT not make a bad cake! lol The finished product was exactly what I envisioned – they did an excellent job. We will use them again in the future for our cake needs.
Our cake was exactly what we wanted both in appearance and taste! They were right on about how much we would need and it was great!
I would love to recommended this vendor to other brides!! we were satisfied with the design and the taste of the cakes made and everything was wonderful! We did not have to worry about anything!
Everything was absolutely gorgeous! We asked for many little details on our cake and they made sure we had them all. The cake tasted amazing and looked gorgeous! Thank you!
Would definitely recommend to everybody.
Upper Crust Cakery in Penfield NY is a fabulous bakery for your wedding cake. We chose this bakery after having wedding cake from Upper Crust at a friend’s wedding last year. We met with Julie McOrmond for a tasting and explained what we were looking for. We choose a 5 tier cake and it was absolutely no problem to have mulitple flavors – we had vanilla, chocolate, confetti, and pumpkin spice (with a salted carmel filling – was fabulous). My daughter gave Julie a picture of what she wanted and when we saw the cake set up at the reception, it was exactly what my daughter envisioned. The butter cream frosting was delicious, the cake was very moist, and it went quickly. It was so delicious, guests were having a second piece! This bakery is a real gem and you will not be disappointed at choosing Upper Crust for your wedding cake!